Trump moves to ban TikTok, WeChat in U.S. on national security risk
Donald Trump Photographer: Doug Mills/The New York Times/Bloomberg
The move coincides with Trump’s push for the sale of TikTok, the popular video app owned by ByteDance Ltd., to an American company, and it comes a day after Secretary of State Michael Pompeo urged U.S. businesses to remove the two Chinese apps and other untrusted services from their stores.
It threatens penalties on any U.S. resident or company that engages in any transactions with TikTok, WeChat or their owners after the orders take effect.
“To protect our Nation, I took action to address the threat posed by one mobile application, TikTok.
Further action is needed to address a similar threat posed by another mobile application, WeChat,” Trump said in the order against WeChat, released minutes after the TikTok measure.
The bans on TikTok and WeChat mark a significant escalation by Trump in his confrontation with Beijing as the U.S. seeks to curb China’s power in global technology.
With the U.S. election less than 90 days away, Trump is making his challenge of China a central theme of his campaign, where he trails Democrat Joe Biden in the polls.
“This is yet another watershed moment in the U.S.-China technology cold war here where the U.S. government is targeting these two very popular Chinese apps and basically saying they have national security problems,” said Paul Triolo, Head of Global Technology policy at Eurasia Group. “It shows the depth of the U.S. concern.”
TikTok and WeChat representatives didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.
Earlier this week, Trump threatened to shut down TikTok if its owners didn’t sell the business to a U.S. company by Sept. 15. Microsoft Corp. has been in talks about a possible purchase of TikTok, an app that’s been downloaded more than 2 billion times globally and more than 165 million times in the U.S. The software company is focused on buying the app’s operations in the U.S., Australia, Canada and New Zealand.
WeChat is the messaging software developed by China’s Tencent Holdings Ltd. that has evolved into an all-purpose app that allows people to use it for payments, e-commerce and more. The app is one of the most popular in the world with more than 1 billion users.
It’s not clear how broadly the order would be implemented for Tencent and WeChat. U.S. companies like Starbucks Corp., for example, use the service with consumers in China.
Tencent shares fell as much as 4.2% in morning trading. The offshore yuan weakened as much as 0.40%, the most since July 22, to 6.971 a dollar.
Tencent is one of China’s most valuable tech companies, and its Chief Executive Officer Pony Ma is among the many business leaders who serves as a delegate to the National People’s Congress, China’s rubber-stamp parliament.
While the language of the executive orders is unclear, they don’t appear to prohibit people from downloading and using the apps to post videos or message with other people. Financial transactions could be targeted, however. Trump directed the Secretary of Commerce to identify the transactions that will be subject to the order.
The measure would apply to any transaction over which the U.S. could have jurisdiction, and sanctions would be defined by the U.S. Commerce Secretary, according to a Trump administration official, who discussed the order on condition of anonymity.
Banning WeChat in the U.S. could have far greater implications to cross-border business between Chinese and American companies, impacting everything from the manufacturing of medical face masks and Apple iPhones to the inking contracts of lawyers and bankers.
While WeChat is not popular in the U.S. as a consumer messaging tool, the messaging app isn’t just used to chat with friends and family.
In China, it’s virtually impossible to function without Wechat and is essentially used by businesses in the place of email and text messages, which are not used as widely in China as they are in the U.S. Other messaging apps like Facebook Inc.-owned Whatsapp are blocked in China, making it harder to communicate with overseas partners without WeChat.
“A ban on WeChat would be consequential because it would practically shut down communication between the U.S. and China,” said Graham Webster, China Digital Economy Fellow at think tank New America. “There are real data, privacy, and security concerns but they go well beyond these two Chinese apps and these orders just wrap the real issues up in political theatre.”
Same category news
WSJ | Dana Mattioli
CNBC | Yen Nee Lee
CNBC | Arjun Kharpal
WSJ | Rebecca Elliott
NPR | JUANA SUMMERS
Reuters | Patricia Zengerle, Jonathan Landay